Mental Illness To Increase Due To Climate Change

Look out! “Climate change is here, now.” And it is causing an increase in nuttiness and lunacy among the those that dwell Down Under.

Or so says Tony McMichael “AO, MB BS, PhD, FAFPHM, FTSE” and others at The Climate Institute, who are authors of A Climate of Suffering: The Real Costs of Living With Inaction on Climate Change.

This report’s purpose is to “raise awareness.” Of what? Of scientists anthropomorphizing climate, apparently: “a failure to reverse rising carbon pollution levels will see Australia’s inherently moody climate become even more volatile.”

The report claims that after a severe weather event “as many as one in five” will slip down the slope of sanity and “suffer the debilitating effects of extreme stress, emotional injury and despair.” These symptoms “can linger for months, even years.”

In recent years, a body of evidence has emerged showing just how insidious, pervasive, deep and—for some people and communities—profoundly dangerous the mental health impacts of climate change-related disasters can be.

For example: heat waves drive up suicides by “8 per cent”. Also increasing: “Depression, anxiety, post-traumatic stress, substance abuse…including the anxiety of watching reports of others being swept away in floods.” Be on the alert for an uptick in “Numbness & Apathy”, too.

One farmer was found to have claimed low “self-esteem” after a drought. Other farmers kept a stiff upper lip (I don’t know the Australian translation of this phrase). It’s also so that “farmers often demonstrate a higher sense of wellbeing than non-farmers”, but we musn’t be fooled! “[W]hat at first glance appears to be individual resilience may in fact simply be persistence in the face of limited alternatives.” Beneath that smile lies gloom, friends.

Climate change, of course, “compounds the chronic difficulties and inequities that already face many communities.” The “r” word wasn’t specifically mentioned, however.

Global warming, through an increase in both droughts and floods, will force mass migrations and because of that there will be a “heightened risk of stress and tension amongst both newcomers and their host communities.” Civil war?

What about the children! The wee ‘uns are particularly “vulnerable to pre-disaster anxiety and post-trauma illness.”

More than one in ten primary school children were suffering from post-traumatic stress disorder the three months following Cyclone Larry1 in March 2006. Common symptoms included flashbacks, nightmares and general state of distress, all of which may have had a deleterious effect on the children’s education and future life prospects.

Yes, future life prospects. But even worse are the adults’ “failure to act on climate change may, like the indecision that perpetuated the Cold War2, lead to long-lived insecurity and anxiety in young people.” Bet you that was the first time you saw the cold war linked to global warming.

Luckily, those who live in North Queensland are used to storms. Long-term residents have thus learned “ways of coping psychologically with the threat.” But it’s not the time for complacency: “as the risk of more violent storms increases, and perhaps spread seasonally, with global warming, we can expect these
normal coping mechanisms to be strained.” So there.

What about heat? It’s not good:

People are better able to cope if the temperature is consistently and predictably hot than if temperatures suddenly soar. Those already suffering from mental and physical illness are particularly at risk. Even people successfully managing their illness may be vulnerable, with psychotropic medication a risk factor in heat-related death. Alcohol and other kinds of drug abuse also raise the chances or injury or death during a hot spell.

The advice that one should ease up on the “psychotropic” drugs during the summer months may be particularly hard for Australians to swallow (or not, as the case may be).

You might have thought there was more crime in the summer because the weather allowed more people to go outside. But several “studies suggest that more aggressive and antisocial behaviour can come simultaneously with high temperatures.” Strangely, there was no crime wave associated with the heat wave across the American south this summer.

How do we save the sanity and “avoid another frightened generation” of Australians? One might have guessed that the answer would be to not frighten the current generation. After all, “one 2007 survey of Australian children’s fears and aspirations for the future revealed that as many as one in four believe that the world will end in their lifetimes.”

Again, no. The best way to avoid frightening is to warn that unless we do something now, the end is nigh.

I don’t want to be too hard on McMichael and The Climate Institute. After reading their report, I find myself depressed, thus proving that thinking about climate change is not good for mental well being.

———————————————————————–

1Larry hit as a Category 5, causing an estimated billion dollars damage. The hurricane led to a banana shortage, and missing their regular sundaes is doubtless what put the kiddies on edge. As near as I have been able to discover, Larry caused no deaths.

1“On the other hand, psychologists and general practitioners suggest that the climate challenge lends itself to positively empowering individual actions in a way that the arms race did not.”

Thanks to Marc Morano for the heads up on this.

15 Comments

  1. Same old, same old cognitive dissonance thing. Past social psychology studies give us insight into today’s dynamics. One study I especially liked followed people who bought bomb shelters during the Cold War. It found that they tended to exaggerate the threat of nuclear war and to discount peace proposals, almost as if they were invested in nuclear war. Also, Leon Festinger’s book, ‘When Prophecy Fails,’ tells of a doomsday cult that predicted the end of the world on a particular date. When the day came and went, paradoxically the believers became even more determined they were right. They became louder and proselytized even more aggressively.

    It’s enough to make anyone depressed.

  2. “vulnerable to pre-disaster anxiety and post-trauma illness.”

    I’m not sure what the symptoms are, but I live in Virginia and believe I got that from all the hyping of huricane Irene. Let me tell you, there is nothing worse than the horror of pre-disaster anxiety and the depression of post trauma illness.

  3. The folks down under have a special problem guaranteed to drive people crazy, and bankrupt. They have a liberal government that buys into all that AGW stuff.

  4. Reading all this AGW doom and gloom got me to giggling so badly I became extremely stressed. Who do I contact in Australia to make arrangements for my check? Fortunately the exchange rate is still acceptable, Mate, or that could be cause for an additional claim.

  5. heat waves drive up suicides by “8 per cent”.

    I wonder how one goes about measuring this. A survey of suicide victims perhaps?

  6. from Hampton Roads, Virginia, ‘Thank you, Ray:’

    “Ray says: 30 August 2011 at 12:11 pm
    “vulnerable to pre-disaster anxiety and post-trauma illness.””

    Local NPR simulcast of tv Channel 3 ?!?!reportage?!?! gave me a sixteen hour giggle, Saturday. We stood hurricane watch at the marina; I cranked the Coleman ’emergency’ radio, and heard excited youngsters searching for ever-more dramatic terms.

    Where are Mencken, Will Rogers, and Twain’s successors? Were there actual persons watching this coverage?

  7. How did they separate the effect of global warming on peoples’ mental health from the effect of having lots of people screaming, “We’re all going to die!” in their faces every day through every medium?

  8. It was interesting to learn from the video that previous to the Black Sunday Fire Storm Australian parents possessed the ability to “affect their environment”. Something they mysteriously lost afterward. Apparently excessive heat or other disaster destroys that capability. Many’s the time I wished for that talent when I lived on the Colorado Desert.

  9. As Little Danny Quayle said, “What a waste it is to lose one’s mind…” Of course, had he been Australian, he would’ve pronounced it “moind.”

    All this dispair makes me despair. I guess the few bright spots would be the hilarious blog posts poking fun at these maroons. Of those, the one above is certainly in the first tier.

    Example: “The advice that one should ease up on the ‘psychotropic’ drugs during the summer months may be particularly hard for Australians to swallow (or not, as the case may be).”

    I nearly fell outta my chair on that one! That was comedy gold, just too hilarious.

    I was once engaged to a prostitute, but wanted to gently steer her toward another line of work before our upcoming nuptials (or as they say in Georgia, “nuptuals”). The conundrum: Should I ask her to give it up? Or to stop giving it up?

    Disclaimer: Conundrums will not prevent the spread of STDs.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *